Ice Cream Cakes

Make Sarah’s your custom ice cream cake headquarters!

We are the perfect choice for everyone in the family. We provide vegan, gluten free, and sugar free options not only to our scoops, but to our cakes as well. At Sarah’s, we believe that everyone deserves to have their cake and eat it too! We have a few different options when it comes to our cakes. Take a look below and see what option fits best for your event!

Gourmet Candy Cakes

These cakes are perfect for when you are in a hurry and need something last minute. We do our best to keep them in stock in our display case at the shop, but you can always call ahead to make sure we have the flavor you’d like and reserve it over the phone.  9″ Ice Cream Cake serves 10 to 12


Gourmet cakes are available for quick instore pick-ups or can be reserved over the phone. All flavors may not be available at all times, but can be ordered in advanced. We ask that you give us a full weeks notice when ordering cakes, if not more. Gourmet cake flavors include:

  • Mint Chocolate Chip: Mint Chocolate Chip ice cream with crunch, mint icing, rolled in chocolate chips, rosettes with Andes mints
  • Peanut Butter Cup: Vanilla Peanut Butter ice cream with crunch, peanut butter icing, rosettes drizzled with peanut butter icing, topped with whole peanut butter cups
  • Cookies N Cream: Cookies N Cream ice cream with crunch, white icing rolled in crunch, chocolate drizzle, rosettes topped with Oreo cookies
  • Chocolate Marshmallow Peanut (CMP): Vanilla and Chocolate Marshmallow ice cream with crunch, chocolate and chopped peanuts, vanilla icing rolled in peanuts, drizzled with chocolate, marshmallow and peanuts
  • Chocolate Kiss: Chocolate Chocolate Chip ice cream with crunch, chocolate icing rolled in chocolate chips, chocolate drizzle, topped with rosettes and Kisses
  • Vanilla Kiss: Vanilla Chocolate Chip ice cream with chocolate crunch, vanilla icing rolled in chocolate chips, topped with icing rosettes, chocolate drizzle and Hershey’s kisses
  • Snickers: Vanilla ice cream with chocolate crunch and crushed Snickers, white icing drizzled with caramel, chocolate and crushed snickers
  • Reese’s Pieces: Vanilla Peanut Butter ice cream with chocolate crunch, crushed Reese’s Pieces, peanut butter icing, drizzled with peanut butter, topped with icing rosettes and whole Reese’s Pieces
  • Cookie Dough: Cookie Dough ice cream with crunch, white icing with cookie dough pieces, rosettes topped with chocolate and mini chocolate chips
  • M&M: M&M ice cream with crunch, crushed M&M’s, white icing, rosettes topped with whole M&M’s



 10″x 14″ Ice Cream Cake serves 12 to 15

 12″x 18″ Ice Cream Cake serves 25+

classic balloon ice cream cake

Sarah’s Ice Cream Cake Sizes

Sarah’s Creamery offers a variety of custom and ready-made ice cream cakes in your choice of any of our handmade ice cream flavors or Penn State flavors in inventory.

 Mini Cake serves 1-2

 9″ Ice Cream Cake serves 10 to 12

Our Ice Cream Cakes are all deliciously creamy ice cream, no cake.  They are made with Real Penn State or Premium Handmade Ice Cream & a Chocolate Crunch layer.

Sarah’s Own Homemade Cakes – here are some examples of cakes we have made – each cake unique


Giant Chocolate Chip Cookie Cakes

(Call for availability) Your Choice of Vanilla or Chocolate Ice Cream!

9″ Ice Cream Cake serves 10 to 12

Homemade ice cream cake